Sour, chewy or soft

Leave out anything with

See all 50 sweets Every sweet and all 14 allergens in one table Up to 2 kg delivered for £3.99 with Royal Mail 48

Butter mints

Buttermints sound rich and creamy, but the traditional British kind is a hard boiled sweet. Here is what goes into one, why there is no butter in the recipe, how they differ from soft butter mints, and the colour warning that comes with them.

British heritage sweets 2 minute read Updated 26 September 2026 4 sources

In this article
  1. What is in them
  2. Butter mints without butter
  3. Not the same as soft butter mints
  4. The colour warning
  5. Safety
  6. In our pick and mix

Buttermints are hard boiled sweets with a butter and mint flavour, sold individually wrapped. The UK retailer Sweets and Candy describes its traditional buttermints as a melt in the mouth boiled sweet combining buttery sweetness and mint.

What is in them

Buttermints, as listed by Sweets and Candy. Sugar, glucose syrup, water, flavourings, and the colours E155, E142, E122 and E100. The retailer lists them as suitable for vegetarians, and warns that they may contain nuts, milk, soya and gluten.

Butter mints without butter

Despite the name, the recipe lists no butter, milk or cream. The buttery taste, like the mint, comes from flavourings: see how are sweets flavoured?

The colours are all added: brown HT (E155), green S (E142), carmoisine (E122) and curcumin (E100), the yellow of turmeric.

Not the same as soft butter mints

There are also soft mints, such as dinner mints and butter mints: soft sweets, often with a higher butter content, that dissolve more readily in the mouth. The buttermint here is a hard boiled sweet, made by boiling sugar and glucose syrup until almost no water is left: see how are boiled sweets made? For a plain peppermint boiled sweet, see mint imperials

The colour warning

Carmoisine, E122, also called azorubine, is one of the six synthetic colours that must carry the warning may have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children: see the Southampton six colours

Safety

Buttermints are hard sweets, and the NHS says not to give young children hard foods such as boiled sweets, because of the risk of choking: see hard sweets and young children

In our pick and mix

We do not sell buttermints, but we do sell Mint Imperials. Each card opens up to show the full ingredients and allergens for the sweets we actually stock.

Download as PDF

Questions and answers

Is there butter in buttermints?

Not in the recipe here, which lists sugar, glucose syrup, water, flavourings and four colours. The buttery taste comes from flavourings. The retailer does warn that they may contain milk.

What is the difference between buttermints and soft butter mints?

The buttermints here are hard boiled sweets. Soft butter mints are soft sweets, often with a higher butter content, that dissolve more readily in the mouth.

Why do buttermints carry a warning?

The recipe here includes carmoisine, E122, one of the six colours that must carry the warning may have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children.

Are buttermints vegetarian?

The retailer here lists them as suitable for vegetarians, and the recipe contains no gelatine.

Sources

  1. Buttermints 1kg, product listing, Sweets and Candy
  2. Mint (candy), Wikipedia
  3. Azorubine, Wikipedia
  4. Foods to avoid giving babies and young children, NHS

Keep reading

New sweets and restocks

Sweet news, only when there is something to say.

New sweets in the pick and mix, favourites back in stock and the odd offer. No daily noise, and you can leave in one click.

By type

By flavour, sour, chewy or soft

Suitable for

Sister shops

One basket for all five shops We are linking sweeties.net to our four sister shops. As each one is linked, whatever you have picked here goes with you when you hop over.
0 Basket £0.00
Start your pick and mix